In the highly competitive password manager market, 1Password and LastPass are two of the biggest heavy-hitters. These two password management tools are regarded as some of the very best. It’s not hard to see why!
Both password managers have a lot to offer in terms of security and features. They take the core functionality of password management tools and make them into a must-have service. With robust security protocols and some handy extra features, there’s a lot to like.
So that begs the question: Which one is the best password manager?
Check out our comparison guide to see for yourself. We’ve broken down this fight into several categories. In doing so, we can scrutinize everything these services have to offer and see how they compare. But before we get to that, let’s learn a bit more about our contenders.
1Password has been around for a relatively long time. Password managers are nothing new. However, programs like 1Password helped to popularize the concept and make it readily available to the masses. This tool was first launched in 2006.
It is developed by AgileBits Inc. Upon launch, 1Password saw some great success. Back then, it was a simple standalone program that saved your passwords vault locally on the computer. That version of 1Password continued to thrive until 2018. With the adoption of cloud networks and the prevalence of wireless connectivity, 1Password switched to cloud-based service.
This resulted in a move to subscription-based service. The move hasn’t stopped the developers from continuing to evolve the service. Even after more than a decade in the industry, 1Password continues to grow. The developers recently partnered with a venture capital firm. With this partnership came millions of dollars of funding. There’s a lot to get excited about in 1Password’s future.
LastPass has also been around for quite some time. However, the service has switched hands and undergone several changes in its history.
Originally, LastPass was developed by Marvasol, Inc. Marvasol built the core program and developed several web browser plugins. The application was a success. So much so that it was acquired by LogMeIn, inc. in 2015!
This acquisition marked a significant change for LastPass. The service quickly evolved into a sleeker and more sophisticated option for privacy-focused individuals. Like 1Password, LastPass continues to evolve as the need for online security increases.
LastPass does have a history of security issues. It experienced a data breach in the past. However, the company’s solid infrastructure prevented thieves from getting away with any personal information. Not only that, but LastPass handled the issue professionally. They were transparent and quick to fix the problem. That’s a lot more than we can say about other service providers that experienced data breaches.
1Password vs LastPass: Security Protocols
The single most important thing to consider when choosing a password manager is security. The technology that a password manager uses to keep your data safe can make all the difference.
We’re happy to say that both 1Password and LastPass implement some solid security techniques. Both companies use 256-bit AES encryption. This robust form of encryption is nearly impossible to crack. It scrambles your data from end to end. This means that the information is locked before it leaves the database.
Both password managers utilize a master password to provide access. This master password is the only password you have to remember. Logging in with the password grants access to all of your account credentials. They can then be used to autofill forms and gain access to your online accounts.
The best part of 1Password and LastPass is that they are zero-knowledge companies. What does this mean? Well, it means that they don’t store your master password anywhere on the servers. No one at the respective companies has access to your password. This provides ultimate security, privacy, and peace of mind.
While the two password managers provide the same core technologies, there are some differences between the two.
1Password takes things a bit further beyond 256-bit encryption. For every signup, the password manager generates a “secret key.” This is an alphanumeric code that you must enter alongside your master password. It does provide additional security. But, it makes the login process much longer.
LastPass also has a unique layer of security. It uses PBKDF2 SHA-256. Without getting into the technical weeds, PBKDF2 SHA-256 turns your master password into an encryption key. It creates your login hash. What’s the benefit for you? It makes it next to impossible to decrypt! It would take millions of years for hackers to go through all the possible combinations!
This was a close one. But, we have to give it LastPass. The unique login hash technology takes the cake in terms of security. We can appreciate the secret key method that 1Password uses. However, we can also see how it would become a hassle for some users.
1Password vs LastPass: Multi-Factor Authentication
Multi-factor authentication probably something you’re used to by now. Most online accounts that provide sensitive information require it. To put it simply, this security feature is nothing more than a secondary way to verify your identity.
1Password and LastPass both have multi-factor authentication. But, they go about the process a bit differently.
1Password has two-factor authentication. There are a few different options at your disposal. If you’re on a mobile device, you can use biometrics like fingerprint scanning and facial recognition. You also have the option to use third-party authenticators like Microsoft Authenticator, Authy, and even Yubikey.
Interestingly enough, 1Password is capable of becoming an authenticator itself. With a simple setup process, you can use the password manager to verify your identity for other sites.
While 1Password has two-factor authentication, LastPass takes things up a notch. It has multi-factor authentication. That means you can employ more than one verification method. This is ideal for those who need optimal security.
LastPass is compatible with a range of authentication apps and services. These include:
There’s no denying that LastPass offers better security when it comes to secondary authentication. Not only does it have multi-factor authentication, but it accepts more methods. It’s a no-brainer!
1Password vs LastPass: Account Recovery Options
Because password managers rely on a single master password, getting locked out of an account is easier than you think. Once you forget your master password, you’re out of luck! That is, however, unless the password manager has some form of account recovery.
1Password offers an innovative feature called “The Emergency Kit.” While it sounds fancy, it’s a pretty simple backup option. Essentially, it’s a piece of paper that you print out and secure somewhere safe.
The sheet includes a lot of important information about your account. This information will be used to recover your account in the worst-case scenario. It’ll have a unique secret key, a QR code, and a place for you to write down your master password just in case you forget.
The system is a bit archaic. But, it beats having to reset your account.
LastPass takes on a more modern approach. Within the app, you can create emergency contacts. These contacts should be people you trust to take over your account in the worst-case scenario. It’s not just for account recovery. It can also help you out in the event that you’re incapacitated.
When you add emergency contacts, you must provide contact information and set a specific waiting period. This waiting period is how long LastPass will hold off before granting emergency access. If your emergency contact requests access to your account, LastPass will send you an email for verification. If you don’t respond within that designated waiting period, LastPass will assume it’s an emergency and let your contact in.
Once again, LastPass is the winner! The Emergency Kit from 1Password is great. However, it’s rather simple. In theory, you could just write down your master password and use that for reference if you forget. The emergency contact system from LastPass is more reliable and covers more potential emergency situations.
1Password vs LastPass: User Experience
Let’s talk a bit about the user experience. Your password manager is an important tool that you’re probably going to use daily. The last thing you want to deal with is a clunky app or slow browser extension. To make the most out of what it has to offer, the user experience should be clean and streamlined.
Both password managers do fine in this regard. But, some Internet users may prefer one over the other because of its design priorities.
1Password’s app is a bit more complex than some others on the market. That’s not to say that it’s very difficult to use. The developers still implemented good design principles. You have an intuitive side menu, tag system, and easy-to-read graphics.
The problem lies in the focus of the design. The developers prioritize functionality over user-friendliness. This could be beneficial to some. The app is very flexible and gives you more options on how you want to set things up. That said, less tech-savvy users may encounter some problems getting the hang of things.
The user interface for LastPass is stunning. There’s no way around it! Next to Dashlane, it might be one of the most well-designed platforms on the market.
What makes it so great? It all comes down to simplicity! LastPass clearly took a different approach than the developers of 1Password. Everything is simple, clean, and very easy to navigate. That ease of use makes the service more accessible to the masses.
You’re going to find a ton of graphics to represent your options. Those are paired with colorful icons and a simple input system.
This category was another difficult one to judge. 1Password’s user interface isn’t bad by any means. In fact, some may prefer it to the one from LastPass. But if we’re talking about the overall user experience, things are just more enjoyable with LastPass.
1Password vs LastPass: Compatibility
Chances are, you have several devices that you use to browse the web. You might have a separate work computer, a smartphone, and a tablet. Having access to your password vaults from every device is crucial.
Luckily, LastPass and 1Password are available for a wide range of devices. Both password managers use cloud syncing to ensure that your credentials are safe and up to date on every device you use.
LastPass currently has standalone desktop apps for Microsoft Windows and Apple macOS. There are also mobile apps for both Android and iOS devices. One interesting thing about LastPass is that you can easily use the service on Linux. While no dedicated app exists for Linux distros, you can access your database through browser extensions.
LastPass extensions are available for the following web browsers:
Microsoft Edge Legacy
1Password is available for all the same platforms, browsers, and operating systems. But, there are a few things that 1Password does that LastPass can’t.
The first is the command-line tool. With this versatile tool, you can integrate 1Password into your workflow however you want! Use it as a standalone client or implement it into a custom script. The sky is the limit!
Another cool feature is 1Password X. This is a powerful browser extension that acts completely independently from the app. You don’t even have to have the 1Password app installed on your device to use it! What does that mean for compatibility? Well, you can use it to access your database on devices that aren’t normally supported. For example, you can use the extension on Google Chrome, putting the service on a laptop with Google Chrome OS.
1Password takes the cake in this category. The 1Password X browser extension is one of the most flexible extensions around. It’s a powerful tool that can improve your accessibility to the service no matter what.
1Password vs LastPass: Password Sharing
If you need to share your account credentials with other people, password managers can be a little tricky. It’s not as easy as letting someone download the manager and log into your account. This would create a logistic and security nightmare.
To help collaborators and families, password management tools often have integrated sharing features.
Dashlane has a great system that can easily meet anyone’s needs. You can share as many passwords and secure notes as you want. All you have to do is move them to a shared folder. Once you request and approve sharing with another user, it’s as simple as moving account credentials into the fold.
The best part of the Dashlane system is that it’s available for standard individual accounts. The same can’t be said for 1Password. Sharing is possible with 1Password. But, you have to have a pricier business or family plan. The sharing folder is non-existent with an individual plan.
Is there any surprise for this one? LastPass clearly blows 1Password out of the water in regards to password sharing.
1Password vs LastPass: Security Checker
Strong passwords are the key to online security. Sounds easy enough, right? Well, creating those powerful passwords is easier said than done. With so many account credentials to remember, most people end up using weak passwords. Reusing the same password over and over is pretty common, too.
Password managers naturally solve that issue. Because you only have to remember a single master password, your various online accounts can use the longest and most random password you could think up! But how can you make sure that your passwords are up to snuff?
LastPass and 1Password have some great security checkers built in.
1Password has an innovative feature called “Watchtower.” Watchtower is a multi-purpose system. For now, we’re just going to go over the security audit feature.
Basically, this feature works by scanning all of your passwords at once. During the scan, it’ll search for weak passwords and duplicates. If it finds any, you can use the integrated random password generator to create a new one! It’s simple but it can make a world of difference in terms of protection.
With LastPass, you get a feature called the “Security Challenge.” It works similarly to 1Password’s Watchtower. But, it has some additional functions that you might find useful.
When the system scans your passwords, it will spot all of the usual bad eggs. However, it also examines your master password! It then grants you a total security score and shows you how you stand up against other LastPass members.
One particularly useful feature is one-click password changes. Rather than logging onto every site that needs modification, you can make new secure passwords it within the app. This feature isn’t available for all sites. However, the collection of compatible sites is always growing.
LastPass just barely squeaked by 1Password on this one. The one-click password changer is just too convenient to ignore!
1Password vs LastPass: Vault Flexibility
When we refer to vault flexibility, we’re talking about how much control you have over your database and what kinds of information you can save. Some password managers are far too strict for our liking.
We’re glad to say that LastPass and 1Password are both very incredibly flexible.
1Password allows you to create as many password vaults as you need. This is great if you use the password manager at work and at home. You could create one vault to manage your work accounts while keeping your personal accounts in a separate one. If you wanted to, you could even separate accounts by purpose or security level.
LastPass offers some great flexibility, too. You can’t create as many vaults as 1Password. But, LastPass does have the handy shareable folder! This password manager also lets you save all kinds of data. It certainly doesn’t disappoint when it comes to entry types.
When you add a new entry, all of your options are displayed as icons. You can save:
Credit card information
Health insurance information
Driver’s license number
Bank account numbers
Social security numbers
LastPass even lets you create custom items if one of the standard options don’t work for you.
Both LastPass and 1Password do a fantastic job in terms of flexibility. We like 1Password’s ability to create multiple vaults. However, the many data items you can save with LastPass is great, too. It’s a draw!
1Password vs LastPass: Extra Features
Beyond the core features, many password managers have a slew of extras that can help you stay safe as you browse.
For example, 1Password has two signature features that work alongside the basic functions of the password manager. These include Watchtower and Travel Mode.
We talked about Watchtower a bit earlier. In addition to the security audit system, Watchtower includes a simple dark web monitoring function. The password manager will scan your account credentials and compare them to a list of known data breaches. High-profile security breaches happen all of the time. In many cases, that stolen information ends up on the dark web.
Watchtower will alert you to any problems so that you can take action and protect yourself.
Travel Mode is another handy feature. It’s built for mobile devices. When you’re traveling in an unfamiliar place, you can enable Travel Mode to get some extra protection. It stores all of your personal information in your encrypted database. Any information that’s stored locally is then deleted. So, if your phone is lost or stolen, no one can gain access to your private data.
LastPass is relatively simple when it comes to features. Unlike competitors like 1Password, Dashlane, or RoboForm, LastPass doesn’t have a ton of extras. The most notable extra feature is the Security Challenge we went over earlier. You won’t find VPN service, dark web monitoring, or any other add-on that password managers like to offer.
1Password has a couple of useful features. The thing we appreciate most about 1Password is that those features are related to the core service. Thus, they’re features that you will actually use!
1Password vs LastPass: Free Plans
Free plans are a great way to give password management services a shot without any risks. Think of it as a free trial. However, unlike a free trial, you can continue using the free version as long as you want!
LastPass has a respectable free plan available. You can access your database on as many devices as you want. This is surprising considering that most password limitations have strict limitations. Of course, you’re not getting everything with the free plan. It doesn’t have the emergency access system, unlimited sharing, or encrypted file storage.
The free LastPass plan goes and above and beyond what 1Password has to offer. That’s because 1Password doesn’t have a free plan at all! The only way you can try the service out is by using the free 30-day trial.
LastPass wins by default here. The fact that the password manager offers a free version at all beats out 1Password.
1Password vs LastPass: Family Plans
If you have a large connected family, it pays to invest in a family plan. They let you provide account protection to everyone in your family under one account. Plus, it opens up a lot of possibilities when it comes to sharing.
1Password and Lastpass both have solid family plans. For 1Password, the family plan includes six individual accounts. Everyone gets their own vault and you can create shared folders pretty easily. The family plan also comes with a unique family dashboard. You can use it control permissions and handle billing from one place.
The LastPass family plan is similar. However, it includes six licenses for your family. It also comes with 1 GB of secures storage for each member and an unlimited number of sharable folders.
Both 1Password and Lastpass have great family plans. LastPass wins this round because the plan is more affordable than 1Password’s. Plus, it includes one extra account.
1Password vs LastPass: Business Plans
If you run a business and need to provide online account security to your team, 1Password and LastPass have you covered. Now, neither of these password managers is going to be your best bet for business. There are many other business-focused password managers with a ton of unique features to take advantage of.
That said, 1Password and LastPass can be good choices if you have a smaller company. They’re ideal for companies with 100 employees or less.
1Password has a simple tier system for business plans. There’s one focused on teams while the other is a core business plan that’s charged per user.
With this core business plan, you’re getting more control than ever. You can modify roles, assign permissions, and keep track of how your employees are staying secure online. For every account, you’re getting 5 GB of secure storage as well.
LastPass has a few different business plan options. These include the MFA plan, the Teams plan, the Enterprise plan, and the Identity plan. Each plan costs more than the last, making your monthly costs pretty significant if you have a large team.
The exact features vary based on the plan you get. However, the top-of-the-line Identity plan has the most features. It costs the same as 1Password’s standard business plan. With that monthly fee, you’re getting API access, integrations, contextual access policies, and so much more. Like 1Password, the LastPass business plan offers a lot of control so that you can easily manage your team.
This one can be a tough one to judge. Ultimately, the best choice for you is going to come down to your company’s needs. We chose LastPass as the winner because you have more affordable and flexible options to choose from. With several tiers, you can easily choose a plan that gives your business what it needs without overpaying for features that you don’t.
1Password vs LastPass: Pricing
For the most part, 1Password and LastPass are quite affordable. They’re not the cheapest password managers out there. But, they are much more affordable than pricier competitors like Dashlane.
LastPass tends to be a bit more affordable than 1Password. The most affordable Premium Plan is comparable to 1Password, as it costs $3.00 per month. 1Password’s personal plan costs $2.00 per month.
However, the Families Plan is a bit more affordable. It costs only $4.00 per month. Compare that to the $4.99 per month of 1Password’s Family Plan and you’re looking at some nice yearly savings.
The business plans are where 1Password and LastPass really start to differ. 1Password has a couple of plan options. The Teams subscriptions are $3.99 per user. If you want all of the core business features, you’ll have to pay $7.99 per month per user. 1Password also offers a custom Enterprise Plan if you need something more distinct.
With LastPass, you have four different business plans to choose from. They start at $3.00 per month per user on the lower end. This will get you very basic multi-factor authentication features. For the top-of-the-line Identity Plan, you will pay $8.00 per month per user. But, you’re getting all of those convenient features.
This round could go either way. The pricing structures are very similar. The reason we gave it to LastPass was that you have more pricing options. The Families plan is slightly cheaper and you have more flexibility on the business side of things.
1Password vs LastPass: Customer Support
Finally, we arrive at customer support. Password managers are notorious for having lackluster customer support. So, it’s an important detail to go over.
1Password has a pretty decent support system. While there isn’t a live chat function or telephone number you can call, there are other lines of communication. The team responds to emails quickly. Plus, they are active on Twitter!
If you would like to troubleshoot on your own, 1Password has a handy knowledgebase. You can find videos, step-by-step tutorials, and more. There’s also a community forum where users actively help each other.
The customer support at LastPass is alright. The main gripe we have with it is the difficulty getting ahold of someone. LastPass offers priority support on several of its plans. So if you have a basic plan or a free plan, expect to wait a bit to get a response.
To make matters worse, it’s hard to get contact information. When you request help, you’re presented with many self-help guides. Before you can get an email address to use, you must go through those guides. It can be a real hassle if you’re in a hurry!
1Password’s customer support system isn’t perfect by any means. But, it’s far better than that of LastPass.
You can’t go wrong with either LastPass or 1Password as your password manager. That said, our comparison produced a clear winner: LastPass!
LastPass seems to provide better overall quality than 1Password. That’s not to say that 1Password is bad. But LastPass just takes things to the next level. The service is focused on providing top-notch security at every corner. There are no unnecessary extras. With its simple user interface, multiple authentication options, and powerful password tools, there’s a lot to love about LastPass!